How to Evaluate Location Accuracy Around Singapore High-Rise Buildings
How to Evaluate Location Accuracy Around Singapore High-Rise Buildings
Introduction
Businesses in Singapore increasingly use GPS-enabled software to monitor field employees, coordinate service teams, verify customer visits and manage mobile operations. However, location accuracy can become a challenge when employees work or travel around high-rise buildings, commercial complexes and densely developed urban areas.
Singapore has many locations where tall buildings stand close together. Areas such as the Central Business District, Marina Bay, Orchard Road and major commercial districts can create difficult conditions for GPS-based tracking applications.
A mobile device may display an incorrect location, show delayed updates or indicate that an employee is on the opposite side of a building. These problems can affect attendance verification, customer visit records, technician dispatching and field workforce management.
Businesses evaluating live tracking software should therefore test location accuracy in real Singapore operating environments rather than relying only on vendor demonstrations conducted in open areas.
This article explains how to evaluate GPS accuracy around Singapore's high-rise buildings, which testing methods to use, what software features to examine and how to compare tracking vendors.
1. Understand Why High-Rise Buildings Affect GPS Accuracy
GPS is part of a broader satellite navigation technology known as Global Navigation Satellite Systems (GNSS). These systems use signals from satellites to estimate a device's position.
In open areas, a smartphone can generally receive signals from several satellites with relatively few physical obstructions. However, tall buildings can interfere with signal reception.
Two important problems are satellite signal blockage and multipath interference.
Satellite signal blockage
High-rise buildings can block direct signals from navigation satellites. When a device cannot receive enough suitable satellite signals, its positioning accuracy may decrease or location updates may become unavailable.
Multipath interference
Multipath occurs when satellite signals reflect off buildings, glass surfaces, metal structures or other objects before reaching the device.
The device may receive both direct and reflected signals or signals that have travelled along indirect paths. These additional signal paths can result in incorrect position calculations.
For example, an employee standing near a commercial building entrance may appear several metres away from the actual location because reflected signals affect the smartphone's GPS calculation.
Research on smartphone GNSS performance in urban environments identifies multipath and non-line-of-sight reception as important sources of positioning errors around high-rise buildings.
What businesses should understand: GPS accuracy in an open car park may be different from accuracy between closely spaced commercial towers. A tracking platform should be tested in both environments.
2. Identify the High-Rise Locations Where Accuracy Matters
Before testing a tracking platform, businesses should identify the actual locations where their employees operate.
Different buildings and surrounding environments can create different positioning challenges.
Singapore businesses may need to test tracking performance around:
- High-rise office buildings in the Central Business District.
- Commercial towers around Marina Bay.
- Shopping centres along Orchard Road.
- Business parks with closely spaced buildings.
- High-rise residential developments.
- Industrial buildings and warehouses.
- Underground car parks and loading areas.
- Covered pedestrian walkways.
- Building entrances and service access points.
For example, a maintenance company may deploy technicians to several office towers in Raffles Place. The company needs to determine whether the tracking application can distinguish between nearby building entrances and accurately record customer visits.
A delivery company may need location information near loading bays where buildings, covered structures and vehicles can affect GPS reception.
What to test: Select locations that represent the company's actual working environment. Do not evaluate accuracy using only open roads or outdoor spaces with clear satellite visibility.
3. Test Location Accuracy at Multiple Points Around Each Building
A single GPS reading is not enough to establish whether a tracking application is accurate.
Businesses should test several positions around each selected building to understand how the application performs in different conditions.
Recommended test locations include:
- Open outdoor areas away from tall buildings.
- Main building entrances.
- Areas between two high-rise buildings.
- Covered walkways.
- Loading and service entrances.
- Underground parking entrances.
- Outdoor areas close to reflective glass façades.
At each location, record the actual test position and compare it with the position displayed by the tracking software.
For example, a field employee may stand at a designated building entrance while the mobile application displays a location marker on the map. The testing team should measure the distance between the actual position and the displayed position.
A useful test record includes:
- Test location.
- Date and time.
- Smartphone model.
- Operating system.
- GPS application or tracking software.
- Displayed coordinates.
- Reference coordinates.
- Reported accuracy estimate.
- Observed position error.
- Network conditions.
What to test: Check whether the tracking system consistently identifies the correct building area and whether the displayed position changes significantly when the employee remains stationary.
4. Compare GPS Readings With a Reliable Reference Position
To evaluate location accuracy properly, businesses need a reference position against which the tracking application's readings can be compared.
A vendor's map marker alone cannot establish whether the displayed location is correct.
Possible reference methods include:
- Surveyed coordinates from a qualified survey professional.
- Verified control points.
- A suitable high-accuracy GNSS reference receiver.
- Known coordinates for designated outdoor test points.
- A controlled test site with independently established positions.
For ordinary workforce tracking, businesses may not need survey-grade measurements for every test. However, the reference position should be reliable enough for the accuracy requirement being evaluated.
Singapore has a national satellite positioning infrastructure known as the Singapore Satellite Positioning Reference Network (SiReNT), maintained by the Singapore Land Authority (SLA). It supports GNSS positioning services, including Real-Time Kinematic (RTK) and Differential GNSS (DGNSS), which can improve positioning accuracy for suitable equipment and applications.
Businesses conducting technical or high-precision location evaluations can investigate whether professional GNSS equipment and reference services are appropriate for their testing requirements.
What to test: Compare the software's displayed coordinates with independently established reference coordinates. Record the difference in metres rather than relying only on visual inspection of the map.
5. Evaluate Location Accuracy in Different Weather and Signal Conditions
GPS performance can vary depending on the surrounding environment, device quality and satellite signal conditions.
Although buildings are a major source of positioning challenges in high-rise areas, businesses should also consider other environmental and technical factors.
Test the tracking application under different conditions, including:
- Clear outdoor conditions.
- Cloudy conditions.
- Rainy conditions.
- Areas surrounded by glass buildings.
- Locations with covered walkways.
- Busy streets with tall buildings.
- Areas with limited mobile network coverage.
It is important to distinguish satellite positioning problems from mobile network problems.
GPS or GNSS determines the device's position using satellite signals. Mobile connectivity is generally used to transmit the location information to the tracking platform.
A smartphone may calculate a location successfully but fail to send it immediately because of poor network connectivity. Conversely, a strong mobile connection does not guarantee accurate GPS positioning.
What to test: Compare the location calculated by the device with the location displayed on the manager's dashboard. Check whether delays are caused by positioning, data transmission or software processing.
6. Check Location Accuracy While Employees Are Moving
A tracking application may provide reasonable results when an employee remains stationary but perform differently when the employee is walking or travelling.
Businesses should therefore evaluate both stationary and moving location accuracy.
Create test journeys around representative high-rise buildings.
For example, an employee may:
- Start at a building entrance.
- Walk along a covered walkway.
- Pass between two office towers.
- Enter a nearby commercial complex.
- Travel to another customer location.
- Return to the original starting point.
During the journey, observe whether the tracking application displays the movement correctly.
Check for:
- Sudden location jumps.
- Incorrect movement direction.
- Delayed location updates.
- Missing journey segments.
- Incorrect route history.
- Location points appearing inside buildings.
- Unexpected movement while the employee is stationary.
For vehicle-based tracking, repeat the exercise using a vehicle travelling along roads surrounded by high-rise buildings.
What to test: Compare the recorded route with the actual journey. Determine whether the system provides a sufficiently reliable movement history for the company's operational requirements.
7. Evaluate Location Accuracy on Different Smartphones
The tracking application is only one part of the location technology. The smartphone's hardware, GNSS receiver, antenna design, operating system and device settings can also affect results.
Businesses should not assume that the same tracking software will provide identical accuracy on every device.
During evaluation, test different smartphones used by the workforce.
Consider:
- Android devices from different manufacturers.
- Apple iPhones.
- Older and newer smartphone models.
- Devices with different GNSS capabilities.
- Different operating system versions.
- Battery-saving configurations.
- Background application restrictions.
- Location permission settings.
For example, a company may issue different smartphone models to technicians and supervisors. The testing team should determine whether the tracking application performs consistently across both groups.
Also check whether the application continues to provide permitted location updates when it runs in the background.
What to test: Use multiple devices at the same reference points and compare their location results. Record device-specific differences rather than attributing every problem to the software vendor.
8. Test Indoor and Outdoor Location Performance Separately
One of the most important evaluation steps is distinguishing between outdoor GPS tracking and indoor positioning.
GPS signals may become weak or unavailable inside buildings because walls, roofs and surrounding structures obstruct satellite reception.
As a result, a tracking application may not reliably identify the exact floor, office unit or room where an employee is located.
Some systems support additional technologies to improve indoor positioning, such as:
- Wi-Fi positioning.
- Bluetooth Low Energy (BLE) beacons.
- QR code check-ins.
- NFC verification.
- Indoor positioning infrastructure.
- Manual site confirmation.
These technologies may supplement satellite-based positioning, but their accuracy depends on how they are deployed and configured.
For example, a facilities management company may need to verify that a technician has reached a specific floor inside a commercial building. A standard GPS application may only identify the general building area.
The company may need QR codes, NFC tags or BLE infrastructure to confirm the actual indoor location.
What to test: Conduct separate outdoor and indoor tests. Ask vendors whether their indoor positioning functionality requires additional hardware, installation or configuration.
9. Evaluate Location Accuracy Settings and Reported Confidence
A tracking application may display a location marker together with an accuracy estimate.
For example, a mobile device may report that its estimated position is within a certain radius. This estimate is not necessarily a guarantee that the actual position lies within that radius.
Businesses should understand what the vendor's accuracy indicator represents and how the software handles uncertain location readings.
Check whether the system provides:
- Reported horizontal accuracy estimates.
- Location timestamps.
- GPS signal or positioning status.
- Warnings for low-confidence readings.
- Location quality filters.
- Minimum accuracy thresholds.
- Rejection of unreliable check-ins.
- Distinction between current and last-known positions.
For example, a business may configure a visit check-in process to flag records where the device reports poor location accuracy. A supervisor can then review the record rather than treating every check-in as automatically verified.
What to test: Ask the vendor to explain how location confidence is calculated, whether accuracy estimates come directly from the device and whether the software can identify unreliable readings.
Do not compare two vendors' accuracy indicators without understanding whether they measure the same thing.
10. Test Location Update Frequency and Transmission Delays
Location accuracy and update frequency are different measurements.
A tracking application may calculate an accurate position but send updates too slowly for managers to coordinate field employees effectively.
For example, a technician may move several hundred metres between two updates. The dashboard may display a technically valid but outdated location.
Businesses should evaluate:
- GPS sampling frequency.
- Location transmission intervals.
- Dashboard refresh frequency.
- Delay between device calculation and server receipt.
- Background tracking behaviour.
- Data synchronisation after connectivity interruptions.
- Configurable update intervals.
During the demonstration, ask the vendor to show the complete process from location calculation on the mobile device to display on the manager's dashboard.
What to test: Keep a device moving through a selected route and record the time between actual movement, device location updates and dashboard updates.
Also ask whether more frequent tracking increases battery consumption, mobile data usage or subscription costs.
11. Test Geofencing Around Closely Spaced Buildings
Geofencing allows businesses to create virtual boundaries around buildings, customer locations and work sites.
However, GPS inaccuracies around high-rise buildings can affect geofence entry and exit detection.
For example, two commercial buildings may have entrances close to each other. If the location marker shifts because of signal reflection, an employee may appear to enter the wrong geofence.
During the test, create virtual boundaries around selected locations and check whether the tracking platform correctly identifies entry and exit events.
Evaluate:
- Geofence boundary configuration.
- Entry and exit notification accuracy.
- Alert timing.
- Location confidence thresholds.
- Overlapping geofence handling.
- False entry and exit alerts.
- Historical geofence records.
- Supervisor review options.
For closely spaced sites, consider whether the geofence should be supplemented by QR code, NFC or another site verification method.
What to test: Perform repeated entry and exit tests at the actual building entrances. Record false alerts, missed alerts and notification delays.
12. Evaluate Location Accuracy for Employee Visit Check-Ins
Businesses that use GPS-based visit check-ins should pay particular attention to location accuracy around high-rise commercial buildings.
A field employee may visit several customers within the same complex. A small positioning error could make it difficult to determine which building entrance or customer location was visited.
Test whether the software can:
- Record check-in timestamps.
- Capture GPS coordinates.
- Display the reported accuracy estimate.
- Associate visits with the correct customer location.
- Flag uncertain location records.
- Support manual exception review.
- Capture additional visit evidence.
- Maintain a history of approved corrections.
For example, a sales representative may visit two businesses in neighbouring towers. The tracking system should not automatically treat a GPS reading near the first building as proof of a visit to the second.
A QR code or NFC tag placed at an authorised customer location may provide stronger site-specific evidence than GPS alone.
What to test: Ask employees to perform repeated check-ins at neighbouring buildings and review whether the system consistently associates each record with the correct location.
13. Review Location Data Privacy and Security
Employee location information is personal data when it can be associated with an identifiable individual.
Businesses in Singapore should consider their obligations under the Personal Data Protection Act (PDPA) when implementing GPS tracking and visit verification systems.
During evaluation, review whether the software provides:
- Clear tracking activation controls.
- Role-based access permissions.
- Secure user authentication.
- Location history access restrictions.
- Audit logs.
- Data retention settings.
- Secure data transmission and storage.
- Data deletion procedures.
- Vendor access controls.
- Procedures for handling data incidents.
Employers should explain why employee locations are collected, what information is recorded, when tracking operates and which authorized personnel can access the information.
For example, a company may need location tracking to coordinate technicians during working hours. It should consider whether tracking outside those hours is necessary for the stated purpose.
Location accuracy testing should not become an excuse to collect unnecessary employee movement information. Businesses should limit collection and access to what is reasonably required for their operational purposes.
14. Use a Standardised Location Accuracy Testing Method
To compare tracking vendors fairly, businesses should use the same test locations, devices and procedures.
A standardised test can help identify differences between platforms without relying on vendor-provided demonstrations.
A practical testing process may include the following steps:
Step 1: Select test locations
Choose open areas, building entrances, high-rise streets, covered walkways and indoor locations.
Step 2: Establish reference positions
Use reliable reference coordinates or suitable professional positioning equipment for the test points.
Step 3: Select test devices
Use representative Android and iOS devices from the company's workforce.
Step 4: Record baseline performance
Test each device in an open area to establish a comparison point.
Step 5: Test high-rise environments
Repeat measurements around buildings and narrow streets.
Step 6: Test moving journeys
Walk or drive along predetermined routes and record location updates.
Step 7: Test visit check-ins
Perform repeated check-ins at selected customer locations.
Step 8: Record errors and delays
Calculate position differences and document missing updates, incorrect markers and false geofence alerts.
Step 9: Repeat tests
Perform multiple tests at different times and under different conditions.
Step 10: Compare vendors
Use the same testing process for every shortlisted provider.
Repeated testing is important because satellite geometry, signal conditions and environmental factors can change throughout the day.
Conclusion
Evaluating location accuracy around Singapore's high-rise buildings requires more than checking whether a tracking application displays an employee on a map.
Tall buildings, reflected satellite signals, covered walkways, indoor environments and mobile device limitations can all affect positioning performance.
Businesses should test live tracking software at actual operating locations, compare GPS readings with reliable reference positions, evaluate different smartphone models and examine how the platform handles uncertain location data.
They should also test movement tracking, geofencing, visit check-ins, update frequency and indoor positioning separately.
For organisations that depend on precise site verification, combining GPS with QR codes, NFC or other suitable verification technologies may provide more dependable results than relying on GPS alone.
Ultimately, the right tracking solution should provide location information that is sufficiently accurate for the company's operational needs, clearly communicate positioning uncertainty and protect employee location data through appropriate privacy and security controls.
Test location results near tall buildings, indoor work sites and dense urban routes. Pilot InnBuilt with representative Singapore assignments before relying on map accuracy.